I was reading the description you gave and hadn't seen the pictures yet and I was thinking to myself, "yuck." After seeing the pictures, my opinion has changed. I like it with just the roof blacked, roof and hood not bad. Roof, hood and bumper is a little too much IMO..
It also got me thinking of what a two-tone black and white Commander would look like. Follow the body lines, black on top white on the lower half. Basically where it angles down right above the door handles. Black on up from there, white on the bottom half.