KitKat, you are spot on. I have a black commander and was thinking about painting the inside of the headlight assy the same as the body color, just like your photoshop, only the chrome rectangle you left on the surround, would be the body color too... i guess it would almost look similar to the latest body style corvette headlight assy. Big clear lense over body colored plastic, with just the round headlights/highbeams left. And no to everyone else, I did not mean pain the enitre headlight assy, as the reflector surface is what projects the beam in a distinct patter, besides, i'm sure johnny-law would be all over me for painting the whole headlight assy! KitKat, see if you could finish the photoshop you did, do the rectangle chrome surround the body color also, and change your already painted in stuff the body color of your jeep, I am thinking this would look awesome on dark colored commanders, kinda like the jeep liberty pic showed.
If anyone has attempted to do this, let us know the steps you took to make it successful, and what to avoid.